Our dog loves these, they're great for a quick little treat and training incentives. They have a pretty strong smell so our dog is very interested in them. They're soft and would be great for dogs with no teeth or puppies.

My dog absolutely loves these. The price was very competitive when I first bought the 50 oz bag for $7.88 as an add-on. Unfortunately they have more than doubled the price to $16.66. I will have to start getting them from Chewy where they are still $7.88..

Great price

The dogs love these.

great treat for dog

Tired of going to the local store to buy these treats for my two dogs every couple of weeks great price don't have to schlep it home and they love them all good.

I quit feeding my dog alpo t-bone treats due her ears getting nasty idk if its the red dye or what but I have noticed this issue is no more after feeding her these.

Picky dog loves them, I can't speak for the nutritional value but it's a rare treat so am not overly concerned with that.

We give these to our dogs every day. They LOVE them!

my dog loves them

My dogs love them

My dog loves these. So much that we have to get the big bag. They're a great snack item, just the right size! (Don't have to make smaller, by tearing apart, like some other snacks) my shitzu loves them so much that she hits everyone that comes home up for a few of them. The price is also not bad for this size bag.

My dog loves these, and they are great for training, because they don't make a mess in my pocket, but are easy to break into small pieces with my fingers. I'd call them a really good value.

Great econo bag, price is right. Everyone enjoys them. Delivered on time.

Our dog loves these, and always wants more!! She seems to have a smile on her face when I am about to give her 1 or 2 of these treats.

My dog loves these but I have decided to stop giving them to her because of what I read in this article: https://www.petful.com/food/canine-carry-outs-recall-rumors/ which I suggest everyone read. I found it because I was curious about all the 1-star ratings that said this product was poisonous, had had a recall by the FDA, etc. ALL of which turn out to be UNTRUE and rumors started on the internet based on a posting by a vet on her FB page which was filled with misleading information that went viral. The website I cite above is an impartial site that investigated these claims and did a very thorough report on their results which are very enlightening. However, even though my dog really loves these treats, the reason I've decided not to continue buying them is also based on the information in the above article which talks about the fact that the ingredients are not very healthy for dogs, and says that dogs 34;don't need to be eating them.34; They don't say they SHOULDN'T eat them, which is important - it's only an opinion they express which I appreciate. But as I do try to be fairly conscious of the chemicals etc that I give my dog I think I'd rather be more conservative when it comes to this treat. Nothing has been proven to be wrong with it, it hasn't been proven to be dangerous or harmful to any pet, and the company that makes it, Smuckers is a very reputable company. I also liked the fact that it is made in the US. So I'm not trying to convince anyone one way or another. I just wanted to set the record straight.

Probably not the healthiest treats on the market, but they're made in the US and our dogs love 'em.

5 stars

Great price especially compared to Beggin34; Strips. My picky eater loves them. I will definitely be purchasing more.

My 3 dogs don’t like these quite as well as Pupperonis for bedtime snack. But I change up between the two. These are less salty, so seem healthier to me. But seriously, they are snacks, not full time food. So I’m not super concerned. Nice size chunks. Not greasy or messy.