Very pleased with the brand overall, especially the Wilderness products. I like that I can use these to add small amounts of beef and liver to my cat's healthy indoor diet, and he loves them. Unfortunately he tends to swallow them whole, so he is not getting the benefit of the burst and it worries me that this habit could cause him physical problems. I actually had the same issue with a different brand's similar, soft-middle treat. However, they had the insight to start making their treat in two sizes, with one being larger than the standard. I tried these with my cat and it was effective, with the larger pieces giving him pause to chew it before swallowing, but I am not so happy with that brand in general or their ingredients. I also give him another brand's fully soft treats which are larger and he chews those as well. SO...I like this brand but I wish they would offer these treats in a larger size. Otherwise I will not be purchasing more for my cat.
Rating: [4 of 5 Stars!]