I would probably give 3.5 stars.. there's really nothing 'wrong' with the boot - but - a bit as I expected - they are a bit narrow for my legs. I'm 5'834; and medium sized, but solid 1534; calves... these boots could fit, but the lace-up kind of ended up looking 34;gape-y34; - not tight and neat. I returned the boots, the return process was super-smooth and easy.
Rating: [4 of 5 Stars!]