I ordered this to replace the flimsy one I've been using for a year. I don't remember what the brand is for the other one, but this brand is definitely far better. When you slide the sock onto it, it doesn't collapse so you cannot put your foot in it. This one will hold up to daily use. Definitely a lifesaver for me since I cannot bend over or cross my leg to put on socks due to back issues that will never go away.
Rating: [5 of 5 Stars!]