I bought this to replace a very similar Columbia jacket that I had for years. Just like the old one, it fits perfectly, feels great, and is comfortable in a very wide range of temperatures.I did not give it 5 stars because of a single design change they made. The old jacket was stretchy at the wrist, making it easy to get either my bare hand or a gloved hand through. For some reason, they made this jacket have a velcro at the wrist. Now, I have to adjust it for if I have gloves or not. Also, snow and velcro do not mix well. Lastly, velcro wears out over time. This one design change lost a star for me.