Imo its 5 stars when you factor in the low price. There are some issues. The fabric is not soft, its slightly stiff. I dont know if its due to the Beefy nature, which it is, noticeably thick. The fit is large, the sleeves in particular are too long and they are bunched up at my wrist. I would recommend buying a size down. But again, for the price espc, they are great shirts.
Rating: [5 of 5 Stars!]