I was leaning towards Timberland until I compared both. Yes, I suggest buying both and sending one back. I watched all the reviews and it had nothing to do with price, it had everything to do with comfort and the Cat Second Shift wins hands down. The Timberland has an irritating stitch coming through the inside of the back of the heel and the overall feel of the Cat Second Shift surprised me. The look and feel of the Timberland in your hand is most impressive but that's not the reason to buy them.
Rating: [5 of 5 Stars!]