I'm mostly very happy with this jacket. It's comfortable and warm: keeps me warm in the 40 deg F range. When it gets below the 35 deg F range, I'd wear a sweatshirt underneath, and I'm warm (comfortably cool) down to the 20 deg F range. Repels light rain snow better than expected (but I'd get a dedicated rain jacket for spending extended periods in wet weather). I'm 6'0, weigh approx 215 lbs. and I ordered the 2XL because I'd like room to wear sweatshirt underneath on colder days, and I'm very happy with the fit. I'm not a fan of the fleece on the inside of the collar, but that's on me; I should've thought about this before I purchased, but not a deal-breaker. The fleece collar is just a bit uncomfortable for me when it gets wet. NBD tho. Overall, I'm very happy.
Rating: [4 of 5 Stars!]